Ziff Davis CEO: ‘Not Planning On A Search Recovery’
A large publisher planning around permanently lower search traffic shows how hard AI answers are hitting the content that gets cited.
On this page
Ziff Davis's AI-impressions ratio is not a click-through rate, so don't benchmark against it
On its latest earnings call, Ziff Davis told analysts that organic Google referrals to its sites fell about 37% year over year in the third quarter. The same quarter last year had fallen about 23%, a cumulative drop of more than 50%. CEO Vivek Shah said the company is "not planning on a search recovery". He also said its digital media sites produced about 2.7 billion impressions across AI Overviews and AI Mode, which he estimated was a multiple of the clicks those sites got from Google Search. Revenue fell 5.6% to $289.3 million. Tech and shopping revenue fell 3.8% to $82 million. Search Engine Journal reported the call and dug into what the impressions comparison counts.
What does the 2.7 billion impressions figure actually measure?
Search Console's generative AI report counts the times a link to a site's page appeared in AI Overviews and AI Mode. It is an appearance tally, not a visit count.
Google's documentation treats these appearances as a subset of a site's total Search impressions. Shah described the figure the same way: how often a link was shown inside generative AI features. Any site with access to that report can pull the same number for itself.
Why isn't the impressions-to-clicks comparison a click-through rate?
The numerator and denominator cover different scopes. AI impressions are a subset of Search impressions, while the click total spans every result type, including clicks on AI links.
Google counts a click on an outside link inside an AI Overview or AI Mode towards the site's ordinary click total. Shah did not say where his click figure came from. If it came from Search Console, the ratio sets AI-feature impressions against all Search clicks, classic blue links included. The ratio would shrink if any kind of click fell, so it cannot isolate what AI features cost a publisher. Search Engine Journal notes that Google documents no separate AI click count, and that Google's Gary Illyes recently said there was nothing to announce on adding more data.
Does the referral decline prove AI features caused it?
No. The decline is a reported drop in traffic. Ziff Davis's figures don't attribute it to any one cause, and Shah blamed both Google and LLMs for the disruption.
These are management numbers given on an earnings call. The coverage doesn't say how Ziff Davis measures "referrals" or which analytics source it used. Treat the 37% as a credible direction, not an audited benchmark. Revenue fell far less than referrals, which Shah put down to businesses that don't depend on Google, such as subscriptions and apps. He also said IGN has held up relatively well, in part because much of its search traffic is people looking for game help. Pages that answer a narrow practical need may behave differently from reviews and shopping content.
What should I ask my vendor or analytics team?
Ask what the denominator is, where the click total came from, and whether any AI-specific click count exists. Google documents no separate AI click count, so vendor AI click-through figures are estimates.
That applies to anyone selling AI-visibility or answer-engine dashboards, such as the AEO tools we covered earlier. Ask whether the vendor's "AI traffic" number is observed or modelled. Ask whether it comes from Search Console, server logs or its own panel, and whether it separates AI clicks from the rest. Our earlier piece on finding Search traffic in analytics and logs is a useful starting point for checking this yourself.
Frequently asked questions
Did Ziff Davis say AI Overviews cost it a specific number of clicks?
No. The comparison Shah cited sets AI impressions against total Search clicks. It shows how visible the sites are inside AI features, not how many clicks those features removed.
Can other publishers run the same comparison?
Yes, if they have the generative AI report in Search Console. They would hit the same caveat: the click side includes everything from Search.
Is revenue falling as fast as search traffic?
Not in these figures. Referrals fell about 37%, while total revenue fell 5.6%, cushioned by businesses that don't rely on Google traffic.
Sources: Search Engine Journal, which reported Ziff Davis's earnings call and Google's Search Console documentation.